British versus American Chocolate

Why the American standard tastes like wax to other countries.

Apr 19, 2009 Megan Reilly

Is British chocolate really worthy of its healthier, sophisticated hype? Raised on American chocolate, one might be skeptical--until comparing the labels.

As many a California native might agree, the American Hershey bar was a childhood staple. To assume that the taste is universally appreciated, though, is as confusing to the ears of British citizens as it might be to an American to hear other countries call their beloved chocolate wax-like in flavor. But, according to a New York Times article, "World's Best Candybar? English of Course," on the subject of American and British treats, the world does have grounds to question the standards of quality when it comes to American taste.

Besides citing several opinions, the New York times also substantiated the article's "sour" comments against American chocolate flavor with the facts--as far as cocoa content, British candy simply has more of it. American chocolate substitutes some of the coca for sugar.

For example, though the Cadbury bar looks practically identical in America and Britain, the nutrition label on the Cadbury bar that Britain knows changes after it crosses the Atlantic ocean and arrives in Hershey, Pa. Further processing adds more to the mix--most of which isn't nutritious at all. The ingredients list on both wrappers reveals the first big difference: higher sugar content in American chocolate. Tony Bilsborough, a spokesman for Cadbury-Schweppes in Britain, was cited as saying that the company changes the taste to appeal to the preferences of that country.

“I imagine it’s down to the final processing and the blending,” Bilsborough said, further pointing to the Hershey bar and its artificial flavors as the standard that causes the change.

The American diet is to blame for the preference for sweeter, less pure chocolate, according to chemist and teacher Ernest Capraro, a writer for Helium.com. In his article, "An American's Guide to Buying European Chocolate," he explained why Americans might mistakenly think that the fault is with European chocolate for tasting bitter to them.

"Europeans don't tend to saturate their diet with corn syrup sweetened foods the way we do, and don't need everything to be artificially sweetened," Capraro wrote. "This also contributes to the slight bitterness that Americans may perceive when eating European chocolates. There's less sugar covering up the actual flavor of the chocolate. (Pure cocoa is bitter.)"

To join the American versus British chocolate debate, contribute to Yahoo! answers, where one poster asked, "Why is British Chocolate so much nicer than American?." And so it seems that, label differences aside, the debate for the truly best-tasting chocolate continues is simply a matter of that--taste.

The copyright of the article British versus American Chocolate in Food Trends is owned by Megan Reilly. Permission to republish British versus American Chocolate in print or online must be granted by the author in writing.
American Cadbury Bar, James Burrage American Cadbury Bar
British Cadbury Bar, Jolly Grub British Cadbury Bar
 
What do you think about this article?

NOTE: Because you are not a Suite101 member, your comment will be moderated before it is viewable.
post your comment
What is 0+10?

Comments

Apr 20, 2009 12:35 PM
Guest :
I know for a fact that a Kuwaiti Kit Kat bar is better than an American one. So it's no surprise that Americans are dropping the ball on their chocolate.
-Andrew
Apr 20, 2009 1:43 PM
Guest :
My English cousins prefer Belgian chocolate over English, but they would take anything over American. Now I know why. The higher sugar content here in the U.S. is not a plus for those of us who usually lessen the amount of sugar in whatever we cook, and avoid it away from home (except for chocolate!). It sounds like the same problem as with salt - pretty soon it all tastes like the flavoring rather than the supposedly main ingredient itself.
2 Comments